Reviewed by HootRated editorial · Last updated
A good horse
Jane Smiley
The text is written at a 7th grade reading level, the subject matter is intended for middle graders (ages 9–12), and the content has moderate intensity with some emotionally heavy themes. Its HootRating code, ME, means moderate content, mostly emotional.
We may earn a commission from these links.
About This Book
Abby Lovitt's favorite colt, Jack, might be the most valuable horse on her family's California ranch, but only because his mother may have been stolen. Nobody wants to say it out loud, and Abby has to decide whether doing the right thing means letting go of the horse she loves most. Some choices matter more than any prize.
Quick Assessment
Set on a 1960s California horse ranch, the story follows eighth-grader Abby as she learns that her beloved colt's mother may have been taken unlawfully, forcing her to weigh keeping Jack against doing what is right. Parents should know the emotional weight centers on the possible loss of an animal and a family's moral dilemma, with light references to Christian faith and a swindle at its core, but there is no violence or romance. It works well as a gentle conversation starter about honesty and fairness.
Why we rated A good horse ME (Moderate)
A good horse is written at a Level 7-8 reading level across 246 pages. Middle Grades (Ages 9-12) is the typical interest range for this book — readers in that age band have the maturity and attention span suited to the story, separate from whether they can decode the words.
We rate A good horse as ME (Moderate, mostly emotional) because the content sits in the "Moderate" range — moderate conflict that may involve loss, scary scenes, or interpersonal stakes. The strongest signals come from emotional weight — these are the dimensions parents should evaluate against their reader's tolerance.
Specific content flags noted by reviewers: Possible loss of a beloved animal, Theft and swindling, Light religious themes.
Thematically, A good horse explores family, coming of age, and mystery — these threads give the book room to mean different things to different readers.
Good fit for
- ✓ Children in the Ages 9-12 range — the maturity and attention span match the story's pacing.
- ✓ Readers ready to talk through themes after they finish — there's enough substance for a meaningful conversation.
- ✓ Kids drawn to stories about family, coming of age, mystery.
Maybe not for
- ! Readers who get easily upset by emotional or moderately dark scenes — the conflict here is real, not just background flavor.
- ! Children currently coping with grief — the themes may hit close to home.
For Parents
Content Intensity
ME · Moderate · EmotionalReading the HootRating code: the first letter is the content intensity (C = Gentle · L = Mild · M = Moderate · I = Intense · V = Very Intense); the second, when there is one, is the kind of content that drives it (E = Emotional · P = Physical · S = Social · T = Thematic). Reading level and age range are rated separately. How we rate
Real stakes and emotional weight. May include sustained danger, loss, or bullying.
Content Flags
Was our "Moderate" content intensity rating accurate for this book?
Reading Insights
Discussion Potential
4/10Good conversation starter with themes worth exploring together.
Book DNA
Multi-dimensional content fingerprint
If your child liked this book, they might like these
Matched on content and themes — all rated for reading level and content intensity.
My friend Flicka
Mary O'Hara
My friend Flicka
Mary O'Hara
True Blue
Jane Smiley
True Blue
Jane Smiley
Pie in the Sky
Jane Smiley
Pie in the Sky
Jane Smiley
A winning gift
Cathy Hapka
A winning gift
Cathy Hapka
The black stallion's courage
Walter Farley
The black stallion's courage
Walter Farley
Yatimah
Cathy Hapka
Yatimah
Cathy Hapka
Gabriel's triumph
Alison Hart
Gabriel's triumph
Alison Hart
Red River stallion
Troon Harrison
Red River stallion
Troon Harrison
Details
Book Length
- ISBN
- 9780375862298
- Pages
- 246
- Publisher
- Knopf Books for Young Readers
- Published
- 2010
- Type
- Fiction